Blog
The Brutal Truth About Why Your Team Keeps Stuffing Up Customer Calls (And It's Not What You Think)
Other Blogs of Interest:
Look, I'm going to be blunt here because someone needs to say it. After seventeen years of watching businesses hemorrhage customers through shocking phone etiquette, I've realised most companies are solving the wrong bloody problem entirely.
Everyone's obsessing over scripts and compliance when the real issue is something far more fundamental. Your team isn't failing because they don't know what to say – they're failing because they've never learned how to actually listen to what customers are really asking for.
The Script Fallacy That's Killing Customer Service
Here's my first controversial opinion: customer service scripts are largely useless in 2025. Worse than useless, actually – they're actively harmful.
I watched a telecommunications company spend $180,000 on a new script system last year. Six months later, their customer satisfaction scores had actually dropped. The staff sounded like robots reading from teleprompters, and customers could tell immediately they weren't having a genuine conversation.
But here's where it gets interesting. The same company had three team members who consistently received glowing feedback despite never following the scripts properly. When I dug deeper, I discovered these three had something their colleagues lacked: they actually cared about solving problems rather than ticking boxes.
The difference was stark. While most staff were mentally preparing their next scripted response, these three were actively listening to understand the customer's actual situation. Revolutionary stuff, right?
Why Emotional Intelligence Trumps Product Knowledge Every Time
This brings me to my second unpopular opinion: emotional intelligence matters more than technical expertise in customer service roles.
I know, I know. Every hiring manager wants someone who knows the products inside out. But I've seen brilliant technical experts absolutely destroy customer relationships because they couldn't read the room. Meanwhile, someone with average product knowledge but high EQ can turn an angry customer into a brand ambassador.
Take Bunnings, for example. Their staff might not always know exactly which screw you need for your specific project, but they'll walk you through the store, ask the right questions, and make you feel heard. That's emotional intelligence for managers in action, and it's why people keep going back.
Compare that to the computer store where the teenager behind the counter knows every specification by heart but rolls their eyes when you can't explain your problem in technical terms. Which experience would you prefer?
The Hidden Cost of Rushing Through Calls
Most businesses track the wrong metrics entirely. Call duration, calls per hour, resolution time – all important, sure. But what about the calls that never happen because customers gave up? What about the word-of-mouth damage from frustrated interactions?
I worked with a insurance company whose metrics looked fantastic on paper. Average call time: 4.2 minutes. Customer satisfaction: 78%. Resolution rate: 94%. Management was thrilled.
Then we started tracking follow-up calls and complaints escalated to supervisors. Turns out, 67% of "resolved" issues weren't actually resolved – customers just got tired of repeating themselves and hung up. The real cost wasn't measured in minutes per call, but in lost policies and damaged reputation.
The breakthrough came when they stopped timing routine calls entirely. Revolutionary, right? Instead, they measured genuine resolution rates and customer effort scores. Suddenly, staff could take the time needed to actually help people properly.
The Australian Advantage We're Squandering
Here's something that frustrates me no end. Australians have a natural conversational style that should make us world-class at customer service. We're direct, friendly, and generally willing to have a chat. Yet somehow, corporate Australia has trained this out of most customer service teams.
I've noticed our best performing teams in Sydney, Melbourne, and Brisbane share common traits. They're allowed to be themselves on calls. They can make decisions without escalating everything to supervisors. And crucially, they're measured on outcomes, not processes.
But too many organisations are trying to create call centre clones who sound like they've been through the same personality-removal programme. It's madness.
The Training That Actually Works (Spoiler: It's Not More Training)
After years of running workshops and seeing mixed results, I've concluded that traditional customer service training is mostly ineffective. Not because the content is wrong, but because it focuses on the wrong things entirely.
Most training teaches people what to do in specific scenarios. But customer service isn't about scenarios – it's about principles. Teach someone to genuinely care about helping people, give them decision-making authority, and they'll figure out the specifics.
The best improvement I ever saw came from a retail chain that stopped formal training entirely for three months. Instead, they paired new staff with their best performers and let them shadow real interactions. No classroom sessions, no role-playing exercises, just watching experts handle actual situations.
Results? New staff confidence increased by 43%, and customer complaints dropped to historic lows.
Sometimes the best solution is the simplest one.
What Good Leadership Actually Looks Like
This whole issue usually traces back to management, doesn't it? I've seen too many supervisors who treat customer service like a production line rather than relationship management. They're counting widgets when they should be developing people.
The companies getting this right have leaders who actually listen to their teams' feedback about customer interactions. They trust their staff enough to make decisions without constant approval. And they measure success by customer loyalty, not call volumes.
It's not rocket science, but it does require courage. Courage to trust your people, courage to measure what matters, and courage to prioritise long-term relationships over short-term metrics.
The Simple Fix Most Companies Won't Try
Want to know the fastest way to improve your customer service? Stop measuring call duration for two weeks and see what happens. I guarantee your team will start having better conversations when they're not watching the clock.
Of course, most companies won't try this because it feels risky. But continuing with the current approach that everyone knows isn't working properly? That's apparently not risky at all.
Look, customer service isn't complicated. People want to feel heard, understood, and helped. Everything else is just corporate theatre that gets in the way of genuine human connection.
The companies that figure this out first will have a massive competitive advantage. The rest will keep wondering why their customer satisfaction scores remain stubbornly mediocre.
Related Training Resources: